CLMTv1.5 vs. PsportableV3 the Rematch!!!

Ok look...
PSPortableV3


CLMTv1.5


When I look at this two, I look first at which one has a better overall likeness to me.. When I look at yours, it is a bit dull, and PSPortableV3s is just a little more brighter and colorful to me...
After, I look closer and look at the details.. For PSPortableV3s, I like the blending done and the transparent lines.. His font is also really nice to!

I am not trying to say that yours is bad CLMT, but I just like PSPortableV3s better this time...

No i know im just sayin that thats the way i made it.

My rating:

PsportableV3:
Technical: 9
Originality: 8
Quality: 10
Total: 27

CLMTv1.5:
Technical: 8
Originality: 8
Quality: 8
Total: 24

Critique:
Both are awesome!! I could never do that good of a job!! But I like PsportableV3's version best.. because of the sharpness and quality he put that enriches the banner.

just my .02 cents.

Thanks you guys so far on the votes. Keep it up

psportable gets mine mostly cuz of blur brightness and colour.

psportable gets mine mostly cuz of blur brightness and colour.

someone is here who should be challanging me...

ok i like them both raiden neaat sword and all. snake is a really cool pic 2

i have no comment or vote

psportable? What does thientam mean? I know I've seen that name before.. but where?? That escapes me right now.

i gotta go with PSPortable for this one, not because hes my bro, but because of his work.
it was a tough one to decide. they were both good, but only one can get the vote.

the reason why i am going with Port is becuase his have more of a custom feel to it, because he added effects and image manipulation. Where CLMT is just basic cut and blending it into the background, i gotta say this is the best one u have done so far.

CLMT is on his way to being a tough competitor.

anyways, my vote goes to PSPortable.

psportable? What does thientam mean? I know I've seen that name before.. but where?? That escapes me right now.

haha, Thientam is my real name. and that's for the votes so far.

4 - 1 me!

Thanks manh and the ppl who voted.

I go Thientam becuase his images i thought were alot better then the ones that CLMT used.

Thanks. I think that's it, that's final. We have a winner...ME!

That was actually a good competition, but don't worry, there will be a "next time". Nice job CLMT and you voters, thanks for being fair

Thanks and believe me their will b a next time but i agree that was a good competition and thanks again everyone.